The Lofton Files: With Peyton or Without Peyton


Peyton Manning has won the NFL MVP award a record four times after being selected first overall in the 1998 draft. Leading up to that draft, the big decision was between Manning or Washington State’s Ryan Leaf. I admit I was a Leaf guy. Both quarterbacks had size and great arms. Manning had made Tennessee an annual SEC title contender and Leaf had just taken the Cougars to the Rose Bowl. Fast forward a decade or so and Manning is touting himself as a “6’5″, 230 pound, quarterback with a laser rocket arm” in one of his many tongue-in-cheek commercials. If only I would’ve known way back in ’98…

I was watching a movie recently that reminded me of the 2011 Colts season. In last year’s “Knight and Day,” Tom Cruise gives Cameron Diaz a quick lecture, while gesturing with his hands about her chances of survival if she sticks with him or if she goes on her own. With his hand raised high, he says “You’re here with me,” before dropping it way down, “Without me? Here.” “With me (hand goes up), without me (hand way down).” To me, that’s this Colts team in a nutshell. With Peyton, they’re up here. Without him, way down here, regardless of whether the guy under center has Collins or Painter on the back of his jersey. (Ed note: You can see the speech here at the 1:15 mark.)

Whether it’s pitching credit cards or televisions, we laugh at Peyton’s ability to make fun of himself and his fame. We love all that mumbo jumbo, hocus pocus stuff he does at the line of scrimmage, flailing his arms. If you listen to the announcers, it’s like he calls all his own plays and his coaches just grin and give a thumbs up from the sideline. While that’s certainly not true and maybe he gets a little TOO much love, think about it: do you wanna be with Peyton or without Peyton?

I don’t have a vote for the NFL MVP award, but if I did, I’d seriously consider casting my ballot for old #18 and making him the first five-time winner. By the strict definition of Most Valuable Player, haven’t the first six weeks of this season proven that Peyton’s that guy? So now I have a question for you: are you with me?

– James Lofton


James Lofton is the analyst for Sunday Night Football on Westwood One. He’ll be alongside Dave Sims this weekend at the Superdome when the New Orleans Saints host Peyton Manning and the Indianapolis Colts. Coverage begins at 7:30 PM Eastern.

More from the File Cabinet

The Lofton Files: Who is The Greatest?

30 January 2014 Comments are off for this post.
It was February 1964, 50 years ago next month, when a 22-year-old Cassius Clay uttered the simple phrase that would become so iconic, “I am the Greatest,” before he stepped into the ring to defeat Sonny Liston. Clay,…
Read More »

The Lofton Files: Whatever suits you – old or new

14 January 2014 Comments are off for this post.
Let me start off by saying I understand fashion, but I’m not addicted to it in the least. For the games I call on Sunday Night and in the playoffs I wear a suit and tie. I guess it’s because I respect the NFL and as a player and a…
Read More »

The Lofton Files: So what happens now?

07 January 2014 Comments are off for this post.
“So what happens now?” That famous lyric comes from Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Evita – the play that debuted on Broadway in 1979 or the 1996 film starring Madonna. Colonel Perón has taken on Evita as his new lover and as Evita is entering the other nameless girl is exiting. “Another…
Read More »

The Lofton Files: Notes on Black Monday

02 January 2014 Comments are off for this post.
Black Monday has unfortunately become a day that NFL fans, players and coaches know all too well. Like that car crash on the other side of the road that you can’t take your eyes off of, Black Monday is the day after the regular season ends, when head coaches around…
Read More »

The 2013 Loftys: Going Above and Beyond

26 December 2013 Comments are off for this post.
“I’m Sally O’Malley and I’m proud to say I’m 50!” Those are the words of Molly Shannon’s Saturday Night Live character in her tight red jump suit and bouffant hairdo, kicking and stretching and kicking. Kind of reminds me of Peyton Manning shuffling up in the pocket. And with that……
Read More »

The Lofton Files: Neck and neck at the close-out of the 2013 NFL season

17 December 2013 Comments are off for this post.
I’m a big fan of old tried and true sporting phrases, terms like “toe to toe” in boxing and “neck and neck” in racing – whether that’s of the auto, horse or human variety. Baseball’s “full count” for the three-and-two pitch is another favorite. Basketball has a great one to…
Read More »

The Lofton Files: Passing grades

06 December 2013 Comments are off for this post.
At last week’s Sunday Night Football game in our nation’s capital I got a chance to talk with NFLPA CEO DeMaurice Smith. Smith oversaw the last collective bargaining agreement, which hammered out 10 years of labor peace and lots of football on television and national radio. Winners and losers in…
Read More »
Load more posts

Comments are closed.